Join Our Team!

Over The Top Online Store

Order an Over The Top Ice Cream Cake

Make every celebration fabulicious! 

Order a Cake

Order a custom, homemade ice cream cake for your next celebration! Whether it’s a holiday, birthday, anniversary, or even a wedding, we’ll make your next event Over The Top.

Please note, custom cakes require a 72 hour advance notice, and can serve from 4 to 24 people. 

Close up of a 6" round ice cream cake from Over The Top Ice Cream, featuring marshmallow and chocolate chunks on chocolate icing.
Close-up of a 6" heart-shaped ice cream cake from Over The Top Ice Cream, featuring purple floral decorations on white icing.
Close up of an 8" ice cream cake from Over The Top Ice Cream, featuring a ring of ice cream cones all filled with individual scoops of ice cream.
Close-up of a quarter-sheet ice cream cake from Over The Top Ice Cream, featuring rainbow decorations on a white birthday cake.

Make Any Occassion Fabulicious with an Ice Cream Cake!

6" round ice cream cake from Over The Top Ice Cream.

6" Round Cake

Serving size: 6-8
$29.99 (plus tax)

6" heart-shaped ice cream cake from Over The Top Ice Cream.

6" Heart Cake

Serving size: 4-6
$29.99 (plus tax)

8" Round Cake

​Serving size: 8-12
$39.99 (plus tax)

1/4 Sheet Cake

Serving size: 16-24
$44.99 (plus tax)

Order an Ice Cream Cake

Gift Cards

Gift Cards are available for purchase! Share the love of Over The Top Ice Cream with your friends and family.

If you already have a gift card and would like to check the balance, please follow the link below. 

Purchase or Check Balance of Gift Cards