Over the Top is CLOSED for the winter season.
2021 Opening Day is March 1st!
Thank you for all your support during the 2020 season. We wish our community a safe, healthy and blessed Christmas season and New Year!

Cakes & Novelties - Custom Orders Welcome

Over the Top ice cream cakes make every celebration fabulicious!

There are ordinary cakes, and then there are "Over The Top" fabulicious homemade ice cream cakes!
We have decorated cakes in a variety of sizes ready and waiting. Several offer the option to add your personal message.
Or, give us 72 hours and we will create a custom cake for 4 to 24 people using your choice of flavor combinations and decoration. Whether it's for a Birthday, Anniversary, Holiday or any special celebration, we can help you create the most delicious custom ice cream cake you've ever enjoyed!

  • 6" Round Cake

    Serving size: 6-8
    $23.99 (plus tax)

  • 6" Heart Cake

    Serving size: 4-6
    $23.99 (plus tax)

  • 8" Round Cake

    ​Serving size: 8-12
    $28.99 (plus tax)

  • 1/4 Sheet Cake

    Serving size: 16-24
    $35.99 (plus tax)