Cakes & Novelties

Order a Custom Cake

Bring the Over the Top experience to your next celebration with one of our fabulicious ice cream cakes.

Planning ahead? Place your order at least 4 days in advance, and we’ll craft a custom ice cream cake for 6 to 24 people. Choose your flavor combinations and decorations to suit your preferences. Whether it’s for a Birthday, Anniversary, Holiday or any special occasion, we can help you celebrate the moment with one of our beautiful and delicious cakes!

Ready to Go Cakes

In a time crunch? We got you covered! Choose from a selection of beautifully decorated cakes in various sizes we carry in our ready-to-go freezer. Several offer the option to include a personalized message! 

Ice Cream Cake Options

6" round ice cream cake from Over The Top Ice Cream.

6" Round Cake

Serving size: 8-10
$32.99 (plus tax)

6" heart-shaped ice cream cake from Over The Top Ice Cream.

6" Heart Cake

Serving size: 6-8
$32.99 (plus tax)

8" Round Cake

​Serving size: 10-14
$42.99 (plus tax)

1/4 Sheet Cake

Serving size: 16-24
$49.99 (plus tax)

Ice Cream Novelty Options

6" Round Cake

Serving size: 6-8
$29.99 (plus tax)

6" Heart Cake

Serving size: 4-6
$29.99 (plus tax)

8" Round Cake

​Serving size: 8-12
$39.99 (plus tax)

1/4 Sheet Cake

Serving size: 16-24
$44.99 (plus tax)