Choose Your Favorite Ice Cream

November Flavor of the Month:

  • Pumpkin Cheesecake

    Pumpkin cheesecake ice cream with cheesecake pieces.  First time flavor at Over the Top just in time for the Thanksgiving holiday!

Seasonal Flavors:

  • Peaches 'n Cream

    Smooth and delicious peach ice cream

  • Snickerdoodle

    Cinnamon ice cream with snickerdoodle cookie pieces

  • White Chocolate Peppermint

    White chocolate peppermint ice cream with dark chocolate chunks and red peppermint flakes - this is an annual favorite at Over the Top!

Regular Menu Flavors:

  • Banana

    Banana ice cream made with fresh pureed bananas

  • Birthday Cake

    Yellow cake batter ice cream with rainbow sprinkles

  • Black Raspberry

    Black raspberry ice cream made with seedless black raspberry puree (Top 10 Seller)

  • Brownie Bomb

    Brownie batter ice cream with cookie dough, brownies and caramel swirl

  • Chocolate

    Rich milk chocolate ice cream

  • Chocolate Peanut Butter

    Milk chocolate ice cream with a peanut butter swirl

  • Cherry Amaretto

    Cherry amaretto ice cream with sweet Bordeaux cherries

  • Coconut Almond Joy

    Coconut ice cream with a hint of chocolate, roasted, salted almonds and a fudge ribbon

  • Coffee Toffee Chunk

    Coffee ice cream with dark chocolate chunks and cappuccino crunch

  • Cookie Dough Delite

    Cookie dough ice cream featuring chocolate chip and double chocolate cookie dough pieces

  • Cookies ‘n Cream

    Cookies 'n Cream ice cream featuring Oreo cookie pieces

  • Cotton Candy

    Cotton candy flavored ice cream with rainbow sprinkles

  • English Toffee crunch

    Butter toffee flavored ice cream with Heath candy bar pieces and salted caramel fudge swirl

  • Happy Wife Happy Life

    Dark chocolate ice cream with roasted almonds, heath bar, fudge pieces and caramel swirl

  • Knee Deep in Chocolate

    Dark chocolate ice cream with chocolate chunks, brownie pieces and fudge swirl (Top 10 Seller)

  • Mint Chocolate Chunk

    Mint ice cream with dark chocolate flakes and chunks (Top 10 Seller)

  • Oh Sweet Heaven

    Salted caramel maple ice cream with toffee pieces and a salted caramel swirl

  • Over the Moon

    Tutti Frutti ice cream with mini gummi bears (Top 10 Seller)

  • Peanut Butter

    Rich, smooth peanut butter ice cream

  • Peanut Butter Belly

    Peanut butter ice cream with peanut butter cup pieces and peanut butter swirl

  • Praline Pecan

    Sweet butter pecan ice cream with pralined pecan pieces and a caramel ribbon

  • Salty Caramel Cashew

    Salted caramel ice cream with cashew and fudge pieces and a salted caramel fudge swirl

  • Strawberry

    National award-winning homemade strawberry ice cream

  • Twixted Sister

    Caramel ice cream with Twix candy bar pieces and caramel swirl

  • Vanilla

    National award-winning homemade vanilla ice cream

Non-Dairy Dessert Options:

  • Mint Chocolate Chip

    Mint flavored non-dairy frozen dessert (coconut milk base) with dark chocolate chunks

  • Strawberry Sorbet

    Strawberry sorbet (water based) frozen dessert

  • Chocolate Peanut Butter

    Chocolate peanut butter frozen dessert (coconut milk base) with peanut butter swirl

  • Strawberry

    Strawberry flavored frozen dessert (coconut milk base)

Additional Flavors Available in Quart Size Only:

  • Butter Brickle

    Rich buttery ice cream with toffee pieces

  • Butter Pecan

    Traditional Butter Pecan ice cream with roasted and salted pecan halves

  • Chocolate Chip

    Vanilla ice cream with chocolate flakes and dark chocolate chunks